How to Choose a Bookkeeper for Your Small Business
You’re handing somebody your bank statements and your QuickBooks login. Ask questions first. Software skill is part of it. So is whether they call you back and whether you trust them. I’ve been at this more than 30 years, and here are the questions I’d ask anyone before letting them near my books, myself included.
Start with fit, then verify the credentials
Certifications and software skills are the entry ticket. Fit is about how someone communicates, how fast they answer, and whether their process makes sense to you as the owner. Somebody can be good at the software and still leave you lost about your own business.
Pay attention in the first conversation. If plain questions get jargon back, that won’t improve after you hire.
The questions I’d ask
- "Are you certified in my software?" If you run QuickBooks Online, ask about ProAdvisor certification and which tier. Certification means they’ve been tested, recently, on the software your books actually live in.
- "Do you handle cleanups and books that are behind, or only ongoing monthly work?" If your books are behind or messy, you want someone who does rebuild work regularly. Maintaining a file that’s already clean is a different skill.
- "What does your monthly routine look like?" Listen for a rhythm: what gets reconciled, what they need from you, and when the reports arrive. "Reports by mid-month" beats a vague answer every time.
- "How do you price, and will I get the number in writing?" Hourly with no estimate means you can’t budget. A flat monthly rate or a fixed project price means you can.
- "How do you work with my CPA?" Your CPA files the return. A good bookkeeper hands them a reconciled, tax-ready file, answers their questions, and posts the adjusting entries they send back. If you don’t have a CPA yet, ask whether the bookkeeper can introduce you to one.
- "How quickly do you answer questions?" Books generate questions all month long. A bookkeeper who disappears for two weeks at a stretch is a problem you’ll feel fast.
- "Have you worked with businesses like mine?" Property managers, rental owners, contractors, nonprofits, and service businesses each have their own transaction patterns and reporting headaches. Somebody who’s seen your industry won’t be learning it on your file.
- "Can I read your reviews or talk to a current client?" You should be able to check the track record yourself.
Listen for plain English
Most owners want to know three things: are the books current, do the numbers look reasonable, and what needs attention. Your bookkeeper should be able to answer all three without a glossary. Ask one of those on the first call and listen to the answer.
Interviewing bookkeepers right now?
Bring this list to a free 30-minute call with me. Ask every question on it and see how the answers land. If I’m not the right fit, I’ll tell you that too.
Have me call youHow I answer my own list
I’m a QuickBooks Online Certified ProAdvisor at the Gold tier. I’ve kept books for more than 30 years, over 20 of them as the accounting manager for one company. Cleanup work is a specialty, however far behind the file is, and monthly clients get reconciled accounts and a financial package built for their business by the 15th. Monthly service is a flat fee quoted in writing after a free review, every cleanup gets a fixed price in writing before I start, and the inputs I use are on my pricing page. Your CPA files the return, and what they get is a tax-ready file. If you need a CPA, ask me, and I’ll introduce you to one of the firms I work alongside. I'll call you back within 15 to 20 minutes during the day. I work with clients anywhere in the United States over Zoom and phone, around Springfield and southwest Missouri, and over Zoom everywhere else. All 12 of my five-star Google reviews are on the testimonials page, and there’s more about how I work on the about page.
From a Google review
Highly professional and reliable bookkeeping services. Very detail-oriented and always ensures everything is accurate and well organized. I highly recommend services to anyone looking for trustworthy accounting support.
Outstanding service. Diane provides clear communication, precise bookkeeping, and dependable support. I would highly recommend her services and expertise.
I’m a bookkeeper, not a tax preparer or attorney. For tax and legal questions, confirm the details with your CPA. I keep the books that make their job easier.
A Form 990 on extension is due November 16, 2026. Your CPA needs reconciled, fund-level books to finish it, and that's the part I do.
Filed an extension for 2025? Those returns are due October 15, 2026. Your CPA needs a reconciled 2025 file before then, and the sooner I see it the more room we both have.
1099s for your subs and vendors are due February 1, 2027, and they're built from a full year of entered payments. If 2026 is behind, the last weeks of the year are the time to catch it up.
1099s for your subs and vendors are due February 1, 2027, the same day your payroll provider sends W-2s. If the 2026 books aren't entered yet, that's the first thing I'd fix.
S corporation and partnership returns are due March 15, 2027. Your CPA needs a reconciled 2026 file to file on time.
Individual returns are due April 15, 2027. A reconciled 2026 file is what your CPA needs to file, or to file the extension with real numbers.